Photoroom_20260614_172740.jpeg
IMG_3251.jpeg
Photoroom_20260614_172740.jpeg
IMG_3251.jpeg

Peanut Butter - Dozen (12)

$37.00

12 Peanut Butter Cookies

Packed with Reese's pieces, peanut butter chips, and milk chocolate chips, this cookie doesn't hold back. Every bite is loaded with sweet peanut butter flavor and pockets of melted chocolate, making it a favorite for anyone who believes peanut butter and chocolate belong together.

+ Not gluten-free or vegan

12 Peanut Butter Cookies

Packed with Reese's pieces, peanut butter chips, and milk chocolate chips, this cookie doesn't hold back. Every bite is loaded with sweet peanut butter flavor and pockets of melted chocolate, making it a favorite for anyone who believes peanut butter and chocolate belong together.

+ Not gluten-free or vegan

Ingredients & Directions

Reese’s pieces

Peanut butter chips

Milk chocolate chips

Butter

Brown sugar

Sugar

Eggs

All-purpose flour

Cake flour

Best served warm: air fryer, oven (350°F): 5-10 min, microwave: 5-10 sec

SHIPPING:

  • To ensure every order arrives as fresh as possible, we bake throughout the weekend and ship on Mondays.

  • Orders placed by Thursday at 4:00 PM EST will be included in the upcoming Monday shipment. Orders placed after Thursday at 4:00 PM EST will be included in the following Monday shipment.

  • Once your order ships, you'll receive a tracking email so you can follow your cookies on their journey to your doorstep!

★★★★★

“ABSOLUTELY the best! I personally love peanut butter, and this cookie blows me away!”

Elizabeth J.